Absolutely charming & classic brick Cape Cod crafted in 1948, accented gables & dormer siding, the romantic charm of ivy and nestled in one of Sun Prairie’s favorite neighborhoods! The moment you enter you will fall in love with the gleaming wood floors, archways, white trim & doors plus tasteful updates throughout! 2nd floor owners suite, relaxing lounge/sitting area! 2 add’l bedrooms on 1st floor w/orig. wood floors! Nicely remodeled kitchen ’08, stainless steel appliances & pantry/mud rm/drop zone between kitchen & garage! Nice full bath with pedestal sink, tub/shower & classic tile floor. Basement walls painted white, painted floor, utility sink, washer/dryer & 1/4 bath-toilet! Shaded backyard patio overlooks perennial gardens, trees and clothesline to hang sheets for a refreshing sleep experience! Walk to downtown Sun Prairie, restaurant, coffee shop, stores, Farmers Market, Wetmore Park & splash pad! A/C ’25, Furnace ’13, Windows ’17, Circuit breakers! UHP Warranty Included!
Property Details
Price:
$384,900
MLS #:
SCW2032664
Status:
Active Under Contract
Beds:
3
Baths:
1
Type:
Single Family
Subdivision:
Hillcrest Park
Listed Date:
Sep 14, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
1,819
Lot Size:
12,196 sqft / 0.28 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1948
See this Listing
Schools
School District:
Sun Prairie
Elementary School:
Call School District
Middle School:
Call School District
High School:
Call School District
Interior
Appliances
Range/Oven, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer, Dryer
Bath Descriptions
At least 1 Tub, No Master Bedroom Bath
Bedroom2Level
Main
Bedroom3Level
Upper
Full Baths
1
Interior Features
Water Softener
Kitchen Level
Main
Living Room Level
Main
Exterior
Basement
Full, Toilet Only, Block
Exterior
Vinyl, Aluminum/Steel, Wood, Brick
Exterior Features
Patio
Financial
Heat Fuel
Natural Gas
Heating Cooling
Forced Air, Central Air
Taxes
$6,331
Map
Community
- Address186 Hillcrest Circle Sun Prairie WI
- SubdivisionHillcrest Park
- CitySun Prairie
- CountyDANE
- Zip Code53590
Subdivisions in Sun Prairie
- Bristol Gardens
- Bristol Gardens Happy Valley Addition
- Brooks Ridge
- Burke Conservancy
- Carriage Hills
- Castleton Meadow
- Country Club Addition
- Fox Hills
- Foxmoor Hills
- GARDENS AT WILLOW BROOK
- Glacier Crossing
- Golden Meadows
- Haven at Smith\’s Crossing II
- HAVEN AT SMITHS CROSSING II
- Hillcrest Park
- Ironwood Estates
- Liberty Square West
- Meadow Crossing
- Migration Path Estates
- Norway Road Estates
- Pheasant Run
- Prairie Enterprises
- Prairie Homes
- Prairie View Heights
- Providence
- Pumpkin Patch Shopping District
- Ridgecrest
- Serenity Estates
- Serenity Estates at Token Creek
- Sherwood Forest Heights
- Shonas Highland
- Shonas Highlands
- Smith Crossing
- Smith\’s Crossing
- Smith\’s Crossing II
- SMITHS CROSSING
- Smiths Crossing 6th Addn
- SMITHS CROSSING II
- Stoneridge Estates
- sun prairie industrial park
- Sunset Ridge
- The Oaks Estates
- THE RESERVE
- The Uplands
- Town Hall Crossing
- Vandenburg Heights
- West Prairie Village
- Western Sunset Estates
- Westview Heights
- Westwynde
- Westwynde II
- Weybridge
- Windsor Gardens
- Windsor Gardens Field of Dreams Addtn
- Windsor Gardens Happy Valley Addtn
- Wyndham Hills
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in Sun Prairie as of Oct 10, 2026
125
Single Family Listed
65
Avg DOM
257
Avg $ / SqFt
$660,920
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the Hillcrest Park subdivision, 186 Hillcrest Circle Sun Prairie WI is a Single Family for sale in Sun Prairie, WI, 53590. It is listed for $384,900 and features 3 beds, 1 baths, and has approximately 1,819 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1948. The current price per square foot is $212. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Sun Prairie is $257. The average listing price for Single Family in Sun Prairie is $660,920. To schedule a showing of MLS#scw2032664 at 186 Hillcrest Circle in Sun Prairie, WI, contact your Keith McNeely Real Estate agent at 608.370.4020.
Similar Listings Nearby

186 Hillcrest Circle
Sun Prairie, WI
