ARCHITECTURAL GEM IN THE WOODS. Marshall Erdman designed and built this in 1949, the same year he started collaborating with Frank Lloyd Wright and building FLW?s Unitarian Meeting House. William Kaeser completed an addition and distinctive carport in 1959. The 16 window sunroom addition is surrounded by nature and total privacy creating a magical ?forest retreat in the city?. The low-profile modest house is set back atop a hill with an oak savanna-like front yard, dense woods to the sides and rear, and is adjacent to Reservoir Park. The original house has clear cedar siding, deep eaves, a wood-burning fireplace, and a walkout lower level with a 2nd full bath and studio/office space. Desirable and convenient near-west location with quick access to everything. Buyer to confirm property?s historic status and addition/building/preservation options. WI History Ref # 73325. Maintenance lovingly deferred for the last 40 years. This gem needs polishing and is sold AS-IS. 2026 survey on file.
Property Details
Price:
$540,000
MLS #:
SCW2034585
Status:
Pending
Beds:
2
Baths:
2
Type:
Single Family
Subdivision:
Sunset Hills
Listed Date:
Oct 15, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
1,425
Lot Size:
19,166 sqft / 0.44 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1949
See this Listing
Schools
School District:
Madison
Elementary School:
Midvale/Lincoln
Middle School:
Hamilton
High School:
West
Interior
Appliances
Refrigerator
Bath Descriptions
At least 1 Tub, No Master Bedroom Bath
Bedroom2Level
Main
Full Baths
2
Kitchen Level
Main
Living Room Level
Main
Exterior
Basement
Full, Exposed, Full Size Windows, Partially Finished, Poured Concrete
Exterior
Wood
Exterior Features
Patio
Financial
Heat Fuel
Natural Gas
Heating Cooling
Forced Air, Central Air
Taxes
$6,209
Map
Community
- Address40 Glenway Street Madison WI
- SubdivisionSunset Hills
- CityMadison
- CountyDANE
- Zip Code53705
Subdivisions in Madison
- ACACIA RIDGE
- Alexis Add to Charing Cross Meadows
- Appalachian Ridge
- Applewood Hill
- Arbor Hills
- Aspen Terrace Condominium
- Atwood
- Autumn Lake
- Baxter Highlands
- Bay Creek
- Berkeley
- Blackhawk
- Brighams Fair Oaks
- Buckeye Meadows
- Burr Oaks
- Capitol View Heights
- Castle Place
- Charing Cross Meadows
- Cherokee Park
- Cherokee Park 1st ADD
- Churchill Heights
- Clarendon Hill
- Clyde A Gallagher Replat
- CLYDE A. GALLAGHER’S SHERMAN AVENUE. SUB
- Clyde A. Gallagher’s Subdivision
- College Park
- Country Grove
- Covered Bridge
- Crawford Heights
- Crescent Oaks
- Crestwood
- Door Creek
- Doyons
- Dudgeon Monroe
- Dudgeon-Monroe
- Duff
- East Meadowood
- Eastmorland
- Eastmorland/Lakeview
- Eastridge Trail
- Eken Park
- Ellsworth’s
- Embassy Commons
- Emerald Hills
- Emerson
- Emerson-East
- Fair Oaks, Lot 13, Block 3
- Faircrest
- Fairoaks
- Farwell
- First Add. to Emerald Hills
- Gallagher
- Glacier Crossing
- Glen Oak Hills
- Glendale
- GOLF GREEN
- Grandview Commons
- Grandview Commons North
- Green Tree Estates
- Green Tree Hills
- Greenbush
- HAVEN VILLAGE AT AUTUMN LAKE
- Hawks Ridge
- Heather Glen
- Heritage Heights
- Hickory Hollow
- Highland Park
- Highland Village
- Highlands
- Highlands Crest
- Hill Farm Condominium
- Hill Farms
- Hill Valley
- HILLSIDE ADDITION TO MEADOWOOD
- Hillview Heights
- Ice Age
- Ice Age Falls
- Indian Hills
- Indian Springs
- Jannah Village
- Jubilee
- Junction Ridge
- KENMORE
- Koltes Plat
- Lake View Place
- Lakeview Heights
- Lansing Place
- Linden Hill
- Lost Creek
- LOT 3 CSM
- Madison Square – Riley Plat
- Madison Square Riley Plat
- Madison Square-Riley
- Madison Squre-Riley
- Malborough Heights
- Mansion Hill
- Maple Bluff
- Maple Grove
- Maple Grove 1st Addition
- Marlborough Heights
- Marquette
- McCormicks
- McKenna Park
- Meadow View
- Meadowlands
- Meadowood
- Meadowood Dr Addition Blk 2 Lot 13
- Mendota Beach
- MIDPOINT MEADOWS
- Midvale Heights
- Mira Loma
- Monona Terrace
- Morningside Addition to Wexford Village
- Morningside Heights
- Nakoma
- Nakoma 2nd randall addn
- Nelson’s Addition to Rustic Acres
- Nesbitt Valley
- Newbery Heights
- Nob Hill Park
- North Gardens
- NORTH SHORE
- Northfield Park
- Northland Manor
- Oak Grove
- Oakbridge
- Oakland Heights
- Oakridge
- Obrich Park
- Orchard Ridge
- Owl Creek
- Owl’s Creek
- Painted Post Estates
- Parkway Village
- Parkwood Hills
- Prairie Heights
- Prairie Hills
- Quaker Heights
- Quarry Cove
- Regent Neighborhood
- Reston Heights
- Richmond Hill
- Ridgewood
- Ridgewood The Glacier Addition
- Rolling Meadows
- Rustic Acres
- Sandstone Ridge
- Sauk Creek
- Saukborough
- Secret Places
- sherman Village
- Sherman Village 4th Addn
- Shorewood Hills
- Siggel Grove
- Siggel Grove, 1st Addition
- Ski Lane Properties
- Southern Ridge
- Sprecher Windchime Estates
- Spring Harbor
- Stone Crest Estates
- Stonefield Ridge
- Stonefield Woods
- Sun Gardens
- Sunset Hills
- Sunset Hills/Radio Park
- Sunset Village
- Tamarack Trails
- Tenney
- Tenney – Lapham
- Tenney-Lapham
- The Crossing
- The Meadowlands
- The Turn
- Thompson Sycamore Condo
- University Heights
- University Hill Farms Parkway Addition
- Valley ridge
- Vang Homesites
- VILLAGE AT AUTUMN LAKE
- Village of Autumn Lake
- Vogels Addition
- Walnut Grove
- Waubesa Beach
- West Lawn
- West Lawn Height
- West Lawn Heights
- Westchest Park, Outlot
- Westford Village
- Westhaven Trails
- Westmorland
- Westvale
- WESTWOOD
- WEXFORD
- Wexford Village
- White Oaks
- Whitetail Ridge
- Wingra
- Wingra Park
- Woodridge
- Woods Farm
- Woodside Gardens
- Woodward Grove
- Wyndemere
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in Madison as of Oct 31, 2026
476
Single Family Listed
54
Avg DOM
290
Avg $ / SqFt
$547,074
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the Sunset Hills subdivision, 40 Glenway Street Madison WI is a Single Family for sale in Madison, WI, 53705. It is listed for $540,000 and features 2 beds, 2 baths, and has approximately 1,425 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1949. The current price per square foot is $379. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Madison is $290. The average listing price for Single Family in Madison is $547,074. To schedule a showing of MLS#scw2034585 at 40 Glenway Street in Madison, WI, contact your Keith McNeely Real Estate agent at 608.370.4020.
Similar Listings Nearby

40 Glenway Street
Madison, WI
