Welcome to this beautifully renovated two-story home in one of Madison?s most desirable neighborhoods. This 5 bedroom, 2 1\2-bath residence with bonus rooms blends classic charm with modern updates. Designed by Beatty-Strang in 1937 and featured on the Westmorland walking tour, this home truly has it all; filled with modern amenities, featuring an open floorplan, while retaining its historic character. Beautiful hardwood flooring on main level. Open floor plan offers great flow for daily living and entertaining, centered around a spacious custom kitchen with an island and high quality finishes. Offers generously sized bedrooms and flexible bonus rooms for home office(s), fitness, entertainment, or hobbies. Outside, enjoy a screened, enclosed deck and vibrant, natural perennial (and edible) landscaped yard with hardscaping, patio and grapevine arbor, for relaxing or hosting. A rare opportunity to own a home that blends history, craftsmanship, and modern living in the heart of Madison
Property Details
Price:
$749,900
MLS #:
SCW2020215
Status:
Active Under Contract
Beds:
5
Baths:
2.5
Type:
Single Family
Listed Date:
Apr 16, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
2,052
Lot Size:
7,405 sqft / 0.17 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1937
See this Listing
Schools
School District:
Madison
Elementary School:
Midvale/Lincoln
Middle School:
Hamilton
High School:
West
Interior
Appliances
Range/Oven, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Disposal
Bath Descriptions
No Master Bedroom Bath
Bedroom2Level
Main
Bedroom3Level
Upper
Bedroom4Level
Upper
Full Baths
2
Half Baths
1
Kitchen Level
Main
Living Room Level
Main
Exterior
Basement
Full, Exposed, Full Size Windows, Partially Finished
Exterior
Stucco
Exterior Features
Patio, Fenced Yard
Financial
Heat Fuel
Natural Gas
Heating Cooling
Forced Air, Central Air
Taxes
$10,788
Map
Community
- Address442 Toepfer Avenue Madison WI
- CityMadison
- CountyDANE
- Zip Code53711
Subdivisions in Madison
- Apple Ridge
- Appplewood Hill
- Arbor Hills
- Arbordale
- Baxter Highlands
- Blackhawk
- Bowens Addition
- Brentwood Village
- Carton Crest
- Chapel Hill
- Chapel Valley
- Charing Cross Meadows
- Clarendon Hills
- Cloverleaf Acres
- Clyde A Gallagher
- CLYDE A GALLAGHER PARK SUBD FIRST ADD, L
- Clyde A. Gallagher
- Clyde A. Gallagher\’s Sherman Ave
- Clyde A. Gallagher\’s Subdivision
- Crawford Heights Third Addition
- Crestview
- Dudgeon-Monroe
- E L Gallagher
- Eastmorland
- Eastridge Trail
- Eken Park
- Elvehjem
- Fahey Fields
- Fair Oaks
- Faircrest
- Fairview Additions
- Farwells Replat
- Fieldstone
- Findlay Park
- Fuller\’s Woods
- Glacier Crossing
- Glacier Heights
- GLEN OAK HILLS
- Glen Oaks Hills
- Glendale
- Golf Green
- Grandview Commons
- Grandview Commons North
- GRANDVIEW COMMONS NORTHEAST
- Greenbush
- Greentree
- Griffiths Beach
- Hauser Estates
- HAVEN AT VILLAGE AT AUTUMN LAKE
- HAVEN VILLAGE AT AUTUMN LAKE
- Hawk\’s Creek
- Hawks Creek
- Hawks Ridge
- Heather Glen Addition to the Crossing
- Heritage Heights
- Hickory Ridge
- HIGH POINT ESTATES
- Highland Village
- Highland Village 2nd Addn
- Highlands
- Hill Farms
- Hillington
- HILLSIDE ADDITION TO MEADOWOOD
- Hillview Heights Addition
- Honeysuckle Acres
- Ice Age Ridge
- Indian Springs
- Jannah Village
- John W Tilton
- Junction Ridge 1st Addn
- Knox Add to Summit Ridge
- Lake Edge Park
- Lansing Place
- Liberty Place
- Lincoln Hills
- LOT 3 CSM
- Manor Green Add to Meadowood
- Maple Bluff
- Marlborough Heights
- Marquette
- McKenna Park
- Meadowood
- MEEK-BROWNE
- Mendota Hills
- Mid Town Commons
- Midland Meadows
- Midpoint Meadows
- Midvale Heights
- Morningside Heights
- Nakoma
- Nakoma Park
- Nakoma/Crawford Heights
- Nesbitt Valley
- Newberry Heights
- Nob Hill Park
- North Lake Mendota
- Northland Manor
- Oakbridge
- Olbrich Park
- Old Sauk Village
- Orchard Ridge
- Painted Post Estates
- Parkwood Hill Estates
- Parkwood Hills
- Pinckney Row Plat
- Post Road Addition to Arbor
- Quaker Heights
- Quaker Heights 1st Add
- Rambling Acres
- Raywood Heights
- Reston Heights
- Richmond Hill
- Ridgewood
- Rolling Meadows
- Sandburg Heights
- Sandstone Ridge
- Sandstone Ridge Daniel Addn
- Sanford Holiday Bluff
- Sauk Creek
- Schenk Park
- Sherman Village
- Shorewood Hills
- Ski Lane Properties
- Spring Harbor
- Stone Crest Estates
- Stonecrest Estates
- Stonefield Ridge
- Stony Ridge
- Sun Gardens
- Sunridge
- Sunrise Meadows
- Sunset Hills
- Sunset Hills / Highland Park
- Sunset Village
- Swanton Acres
- Tamarack Trails
- Tenney-Lapham
- Terravessa
- The Crossing
- The Highlands
- The Meadowlands
- The Trillium
- The Turn
- The Turn at Cherokee
- Third Add to Downs of West Meadowood
- Timber Lane
- Twin Oaks
- University Heights
- University Hill Farms
- Valhalla Valley/High Point
- Valley Ridge
- Vang Homesites
- Vilas
- VILLAGE AT AUTUMN LAKE
- Village of Autumn Lake
- Washington Park
- Waubesa Beach
- West Lawn
- West Meadowood Hills
- Westchest Park, Outlot
- WestHaven Trails
- Westmorland
- Westport Meadows
- Westvale
- Wexford Village
- Wheeler Heights 2nd Add.
- Whitetail Ridge
- Wingra Park
- WOODLAND HILLS
- WOODLAWN
- Woodlawn Add
- Woodward Grove
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in Madison as of Apr 24, 2026
348
Single Family Listed
40
Avg DOM
297
Avg $ / SqFt
$608,581
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- 442 Toepfer Avenue Madison WI is a Single Family for sale in Madison, WI, 53711. It is listed for $749,900 and features 5 beds, 3 baths, and has approximately 2,052 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1937. The current price per square foot is $365. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Madison is $297. The average listing price for Single Family in Madison is $608,581. To schedule a showing of MLS#scw2020215 at 442 Toepfer Avenue in Madison, WI, contact your Keith McNeely Real Estate agent at 608.370.4020.
Similar Listings Nearby
442 Toepfer Avenue
Madison, WI